Catalli Insurance Brokers - San Mateo, California

Asia Quan

Our experience with Tony has been nothing short of outstanding. He is always extremely helpful and timely, responding to our needs with great professionalism. He and his team have been amazing to work with, consistently going above and beyond to ensure we have the best possible coverage.

We had a hard time finding a reasonable home insurance price from a reputable company, but he stepped in and found us a fantastic option. No matter what questions we have, he is always quick to assist, making sure we understand our options and working hard to get us the best deals. We couldn’t be happier with Tony and his team!

Michael Grodzicki

When our previous insurance company was no longer writing policies in California for umbrella liability coverage, we were very concerned. A close friend recommended that I contact Tony at Catalli Insurance Brokers. Within a week we went from very concerned about our insurance coverage to so relieved thanks to new policies with Mercury Insurance which Tony found for us. We got better coverage for auto, home and umbrella coverage with just a minimal increase in price. And their service was fantastic! We'd highly recommend them.

andres uribe

Tony was fantastic in helping me set up my Auto, Renters, and Umbrella insurance policies. He made the whole process smooth and stress-free, finding the best options tailored to my needs. His knowledge, professionalism, and prompt responses made working with him a pleasure. I highly recommend!

Jay Lee

Tony at Catalli Insurance was great. He was easy to work with, on top of details, explained everything clearly, and I felt he was always looking out for my best interests. Couldn't be happier.

Jay Steinberg

When I lost my home coverage with SafeCo last year, I was very grateful when Catalli connected me with Mercury Insurance, which gave me comparable coverage for not much more money. It’s no small thing in this region, where many people are losing their insurance and having trouble getting new policies.

I rolled my auto policy over to Mercury, too, and they gave me better pricing than SafeCo. I just received my annual auto policy declarations and was pleased to see that the low number of miles I drive shifted seamlessly from last year's policy to the upcoming one. That was an issue every year with SafeCo, which always increased my mileage to whatever is average. Getting that corrected was an annual wrestling match that I did not enjoy. None of that with Mercury! It's a refreshingly hassle-free experience.

piet vervaet

We appreciate how attentive they were and how smooth the process of securing new insurance was. To top it all off, they also secured competitive rates for us. We would highly recommend them.

Nanette Boerner

We were in desperate need of a replacement home policy due to a pickpocketing situation in Europe over the Summer. It's a long story -- but your receptionist was amazing and got us connected with Tony Catalli. Tony was amazingly knowledgeable and responsive. He got us sorted out immediately. We were so happy with the service that we also switched over our auto insurance, landlord policy and opened a new umbrella policy. Fantastic rates and top-notch service. I would recommend Catalli without hesitation.

Dennis Ross

I have been with Catalli for over 20 years, and I have been very happy with their customer service. My previous car insurance stopped writing policies in California just recently and Joe found me another company with a good rate very quickly.